
Though I hadn’t watched a single show in previous years, I found myself watching American Idol this season, due to the fact that winner Lee Dewyze grew up about 10 min from where we live. As I watched, I couldn’t help thinking how many of the performances reminded me of some of the musical performances I’ve seen over the years in megachurches.
A recent Los Angeles Times article explored the relationship between American Idol and music in U.S. churches. In a nutshell, they described how today’s churches are often perfect grounds for preparing future Idol contestants, due to church musician’s exposure to a wide variety of musical styles, and the high production values at many churches. Said former contestant Jason Castro, “Any of the larger churches you go into are really full-on performance venues.”
To be honest, I’ve got mixed feelings about this. On one hand, I love that churches are encouraging the creative gifts of kids growing up in them. On the other hand, it does speak not only to how performance-oriented many of our churches have become, but broadcast-oriented as well.
What do you think? Does this trend trouble you, or do you think it’s a good thing for both the church and the entertainment industry?